The word mannerism derives from the Italian maniera, meaning "style" or "manner.” The mannerism period of the renaissance was defined by this type style of art that focused on unnatural or unrealistic body proportions, lack of balance, twisted figures, uncomfortable and unstable compositions. The mannerist style became very popular in southern Europe hence the reason mannerism derives from Italian. When looking at the two works of art, Abraham Janssens, The Origin of the Cornucopia, ca. 1619 and Vincent Sellaer, Leda and the Swan and Her Children, ca. 1540, it is clear that they both represent this style of art.
When looking at Abraham Janssens, The Origin of the Cornucopia one of the first things that I noticed was that how the bodies were not realistically proportioned. When looking at the women depicted they are all incredibly muscular applies to the mannerist style of unnatural body proportions. The main woman depicted at the front right of the painting has a huge muscular arms resembling more of an idealistic depiction of a man’s muscles than that of a woman’s. It also seems as though most of the characters in the painting are also sitting in awkward positions which would be hard to maintain for any long period of time. After looking at Abraham Janssens work of art it I noticed a few similarities in the representation of anatomy when observing Michelangelo’s “Last Judgment, Sistine Chapel” painting. In his painting women are represented in the same very muscular way which makes their body look unnatural. Another similarity between the two works of art is the awkward body positions. Although the characters in Janssens work of art look like they are in a fairly unnatural position, there are quite a few characters in Michelangelo’s painting that are in very unnatural positions. When looking at the two it is clear that Michelangelo has taken the awkward body positions, and twisted figures to an extreme, compared to Janssens more moderate approach.
The next painting that I observed was Vincent Sellaer’s, “Leda and the Swan and Her Children.” When I first observed this painting I had trouble finding the mannerist style. But after closer examination I noticed that the children, especially the one in the front left are has a twisted body that fits in with the mannerism period. I also think that the way that the woman is resting her hand on the child’s head and her elbow on the swan makes the composition of the painting a little uncomfortable. It looks very awkward because it doesn’t look as though she is resting her hand on the child’s head because she is comforting him, but because she is using him as an armrest. The awkwardness applies to the way that she is resting her elbow on the swan as well. It is like she is using the swan and the children to help make herself more comfortable. Through the awkward composition and twisted body of the child it makes this picture fit in with the mannerist style of artwork.
Overall the paintings by Abraham Janssens and Vincent Sellaer represent the mannerist style of art through the use of twisting bodies, unnatural body proportions, and unnatural composition.
Hi Brian. "Leda and the Swan" is a little bit tricky as a Mannerist example - I can tell that this assignment forced you to think a bit more!
ReplyDeleteI also think that Leda is quite elongated and disproportionate. For example, check out her knee and thigh (in the foreground) in relation to where her hips are located. Her thigh is extremely long (and her knee is huge, too)! Plus, she isn't solidly grounded in her position - is she seated or partially standing up?
- Prof. Bowen
I like how you mentioned the fact that they all are in very uncomfortable stances. For example the Girl in the swan is in between several positions as safe the people in the first painting. I don't fully agree with the fact that they are completely un-naturalistic though.Maybe in the first painting i can see this but often times paintings still looked naturalistic as far as the bodies went but they were slightly elongated to look more elegant, and although the stances seem strange they are almost always in an exaggerated moving pose which is just a different style of painting humans. features are realistic but the way they are positioned and the colors that are being used make the whole piece seem kind of "dreamy".
ReplyDeleteBrian, you do a good job of describing the various elements used in "Mannerism". I didn't do a very good job of that in my post and was marked down for it. I was more concerned why the artists were using this style and why they had departed from the classical style. Are they trying to capture our attention? Is this a way to better express an emotion or the significance of an event. What are the artists trying to say to me?
ReplyDeleteThe various elements you mentioned all flowed throughout each piece and I liked how you described the elements. I didn't notice a comparison from the book or of other pieces from this time period to help reinforce the points you made, although I did like the mention of Michaelangelo's work.
ReplyDelete